Read a preview
Chapter 1
Chapter 1: The Circle
The folding chairs formed a loose circle in the basement of St. Margaret's Church, their metal legs scraping against the linoleum floor as the last arrivals settled in. Margaret Holloway clutched her paper coffee cup and studied the others from beneath her graying bangs. After thirty years as a homicide detective, she couldn't help cataloging details: the young man with red-rimmed eyes and a wedding ring he kept twisting, the elderly woman with the expensive handbag and the trembling hands, the middle-aged man in the rumpled suit who smelled faintly of bourbon, and the twentysomething woman with purple streaks in her black hair who hadn't looked up from her phone since she sat down.
Five strangers bound by loss. Five people who had no idea what they were about to discover.
"Welcome, everyone," said Dr. Patricia Nguyen, the group facilitator, settling into her chair with a warm smile. "I know it takes courage to walk through those doors. Why don't we start with introductions? Just your first name and whoever you're here for."
The young man with the wedding ring cleared his throat. "I'm David. My wife, Sophie. Three months ago." His voice cracked on her name.
The elderly woman patted his knee. "I'm Beatrice. My husband, Harold. Six months now. Fifty-two years of marriage, and I still reach for him in bed every morning."
The rumpled man loosened his tie. "Frank. My daughter, Melissa. She was twenty-four. It'll be four months on Tuesday."
The young woman finally looked up from her phone. "Carmen. My brother, Rafael. Five months." Her jaw was set hard, like she was daring anyone to offer sympathy.
Margaret took a breath. "I'm Margaret. My son, Thomas. He was thirty-one. It happened seven months ago."
Dr. Nguyen nodded, making notes on her clipboard. "Thank you all for sharing. Grief has no timeline, and there's no right way to feel. This is a safe space to—"
"Accidental drowning," Carmen interrupted, still staring at her phone. "That's what they said about Rafael. He was a competitive swimmer. Made it to state championships three years in a row." She looked up, her dark eyes blazing. "But sure. Accidental drowning."
The room went still.
"Melissa fell from a cliff," Frank said slowly. "Hiking accident, they called it. But she'd been hiking that trail since she was twelve. Knew every rock, every turn."
"Sophie had a severe allergic reaction," David added, his voice barely above a whisper. "But she'd managed her peanut allergy her whole life. She was so careful. The resort swore there were no peanuts in anything she ate."
Beatrice's hands had stopped trembling. "Harold's heart gave out. But he'd just had a full cardiac workup two weeks before. Clean bill of health."
Margaret felt the familiar cold settling in her chest—the instinct that had solved dozens of cases over her career. "Thomas was found at the bottom of a staircase. They said he'd been drinking. But Thomas had been sober for eight years."
Dr. Nguyen set down her clipboard. "These are all natural questions. When we lose someone unexpectedly, it's normal to search for answers, to question—"
"Where did it happen?" Margaret asked, cutting her off. She wasn't looking at the therapist. She was looking at the others. "Where did your loved ones die?"
"Some island resort," Carmen said. "Costa Serena, off the coast of—"
"Costa Serena," David breathed. "Sophie and I went there for our anniversary."
"Harold wanted to see the bioluminescent bay one more time," Beatrice whispered.
Frank had gone pale. "Melissa was there for a work retreat. Her company booked the whole—" He stopped, swallowing hard.
Margaret's coffee cup crumpled in her grip. "Thomas went there with his girlfriend. A surprise trip she'd planned."
Five strangers. Five deaths ruled accidental. One remote island resort.
Dr. Nguyen was saying something about coincidences and the mind's tendency to find patterns, but Margaret wasn't listening. She was watching the others' faces, seeing her own dawning horror reflected back at her.
This wasn't grief playing tricks on them.
This was something else entirely.
