Read a preview
Chapter 1
Chapter One: The Inheritance
The call came on a Tuesday afternoon while Elise Cottrell was on her knees in a stranger's living room, arranging three ceramic pears on a coffee table.
She had staged eleven houses that year. Eleven kitchens filled with bowls of lemons she bought in bulk and threw away. Eleven bedrooms made to look like someone happy slept in them. She was good at it — better than good. She could walk into a room that felt wrong and know, in under a minute, exactly which wall was lying.
Her phone buzzed against the hardwood. An unfamiliar number, area code 803.
"Elise Cottrell?" A man's voice, old and Southern and careful. "My name is Wendell Pace. I'm an attorney in Carden, South Carolina. I'm calling about your grandmother."
Elise sat back on her heels. Outside, a lawn crew was working its way down the street with a leaf blower.
"Betty Fentress," she said. It came out flat, like a fact she'd read somewhere.
"Yes, ma'am. I'm sorry to be the one to tell you. She passed on the ninth of March. Heart, they think. She was eighty-one."
March. It was the first week of May.
"Nobody called me," Elise said.
"Nobody had a number for you, is my understanding. It took me some doing." A pause, papers shifting. "Miss Cottrell, your grandmother left a will. It's simple and it's clean and it's been through probate without a hiccup, because there's no one to contest it. She left everything to you."
Elise looked at the ceramic pears. They were the wrong shade of green for the room. She had known it when she set them down.
"Everything meaning what?"
"The house on Pettit Road. Twelve acres, more or less, mostly planted pine. A barn that's been converted. A '98 Buick that doesn't run. And about four thousand dollars in a checking account at the bank in Sumner." Pace cleared his throat. "The house is the thing. It's a big old place, hundred and some years, and it's in remarkable shape for its age. I'd guess you could get two-forty for it, maybe more if a developer looks at the acreage."
Two hundred and forty thousand dollars.
Elise's mouth went dry. In her purse, four feet away, was a debit card that had been declined at a gas station on Sunday. Her divorce from Neil had been finalized in November and had cost her both her savings and her half of a townhouse. Her next contract didn't start until July. She had been sleeping in a rental studio with a mattress on the floor because she'd sold the bed frame.
"Miss Cottrell?"
"I'm here." She stood, walked to the window. "Mr. Pace, I haven't spoken to my grandmother in over twenty years."
"I know it."
Something in the way he said it — not surprised, not judging — made her pause.
"Did she talk about me?"
The line was quiet a moment. "She kept a photograph of you on the hall table. School picture. You'd have been eleven, twelve. She dusted it." He said this like a man reporting the weather. "When can you come down? There are papers."
Elise drove down on Thursday morning.
Charlotte fell away behind her in strip malls and self-storage lots, then the interstate emptied out into a green country that got flatter and hotter the longer she drove. She came off the highway at Sumner, the county seat of Tulley County — a courthouse with a Confederate plaque she didn't look at twice, a Piggly Wiggly, a barbecue place with a hand-lettered sign. Then twenty more minutes of two-lane blacktop through pine plantations planted in soldier rows, the trunks flickering past like a strobe.
Carden wasn't a town so much as a decision to slow down. A gas station with two pumps. A Baptist church, a Methodist church, and a third church in a metal building. A shuttered feed store. Wendell Pace's law office occupied the front room of a house with a wheelchair ramp, and Wendell Pace turned out to be eighty if he was a day, with liver-spotted hands and a tie clip shaped like a fish.
He gave her a folder, a set of keys on a ring with a rabbit's foot gone bald, and a long look.
"Your grandmother was a nurse for thirty-one years," he said. "County health. She delivered babies in trailers with no running water. She sat with people while they died because nobody else would." He tapped the folder. "There's not many left who remember what this county was like before Medicaid got out here. She did."
"You liked her."
"I was scared of her," Pace said. "That's a different thing, and it's better."
He told her how to find Pettit Road. He also told her, almost as an afterthought, that there was a man living on the property.
"Dutch Newman. Caretaker. Been out there — Lord, thirty years now? He's got the barn. Betty left him the right to stay through the end of the year, or until sale, whichever comes first." Pace shrugged. "He's a quiet fella. Fixed my gutters once and wouldn't take money."
The house sat back a quarter mile from the road at the end of a gravel drive that curved so you didn't see it until you were nearly on it, and then you saw all of it at once.
Elise stopped the car.
It was white clapboard, two full stories with a steep hipped roof and a wraparound porch on three sides. Not a mansion. A farmhouse that had been added to by people with money and opinions, over and over, for a century. There were four chimneys. There was a bay window on the south side with old wavy glass. The pines stood back from it in a rough ring, and the yard inside that ring had been mowed, recently, in neat diagonal passes.
She had expected rot. Sagging porch, kudzu, wasps. This house looked cared for the way a person looks cared for.
A man came around the corner of the porch with a pair of pruning shears in his hand.
He was somewhere past fifty-five, thin through the chest, with forearms like knotted rope and a face that had spent forty years outdoors. Gray hair cut short. Clean work shirt, sleeves buttoned at the wrist despite the heat.
Elise got out of the car and the heat came down on her like a wet blanket.
"Ms. Cottrell." He said it without a question mark. He didn't offer his hand, and he stopped a good ten feet off, which she appreciated. "Dutch Newman."
"Elise."
"Mr. Pace called and said you'd be by." He looked at the house instead of at her. "I aired it out this morning. Cut the water back on. Refrigerator's running, but there's nothing in it. Power's on. I've been paying the power out of my own pocket since March, so I'd appreciate getting that switched over when you can."
"You've been paying her electric bill?"
"Somebody had to. House gets damp if you let it go cold." He shifted the shears from one hand to the other. "There's mice in the pantry. I set traps. Two of them are full and I didn't want to go in and empty them without you here."
Elise looked at him a moment. In twelve years of staging houses she had met every kind of contractor, and she had built a fast, reliable instinct for which ones would steal a drill and which ones would drive back across town to return a leftover switch plate.
"Thank you," she said. "Really."
Something moved in his face and settled. "She was a good woman," he said. "I'm sorry for your loss."
"I didn't know her."
"I know it," Dutch Newman said, and turned to go. Then he stopped. "How long you figure on staying?"
"A week. Long enough to clear it out and get it listed."
He nodded slowly. He was still looking at the house.
"A week," he said. "All right."
And he walked off toward the barn on the eastern edge of the property, and Elise stood in the yard with her grandmother's keys in her hand, and she had no way to know that she had just told the first honest lie of the rest of her life.