Read a preview
Chapter 1
Chapter 1: The Letter
The envelope arrived on a Tuesday, which Joanna would later think was fitting. Tuesdays were her nothing days—no lectures, no office hours, just the flat in Kentish Town with its radiators that clanked like prisoners tapping on pipes. She'd been grading second-year essays on media ethics, red pen bleeding across margins, when the post clattered through the slot.
Bills. A flyer for a new Thai place on Fortess Road. And then the letter, handwritten on cream paper, the address rendered in a careful, old-fashioned script she hadn't seen in over a decade but recognized immediately.
Aunt Agnes.
Joanna set down her pen. She turned the envelope over. No return address, but the postmark read Frome, Somerset. She slid her thumb beneath the seal and unfolded a single sheet.
*Dear Joanna,*
*I know we haven't spoken since your mother's funeral and I know whose fault that is. I won't ask your forgiveness because I don't deserve it. But I am asking for your help because there is no one else I can ask.*
*I am housekeeper at St. Dunstan's Retreat in Wellow Ash, Somerset. Three weeks ago a young woman named Sister Brigid Norris was found hanging in our chapel. They say she took her own life. The police came and went in half a day. Father Veitch says we must pray for her soul and move on.*
*But I was there, Joanna. I saw things that don't make sense. And I'm frightened.*
*Please come. I wouldn't write if I had anywhere else to turn.*
*Your aunt,*
*Agnes*
Joanna read the letter twice, then a third time. She folded it carefully and placed it on the kitchen table beside a cold mug of tea. Through the window, the February sky was the color of wet cement.
She hadn't thought about Agnes in years, not really. Her mother's older sister—stern, devout, a woman who'd chosen God over family so many times that the family had eventually stopped competing. After Joanna's mother died of pancreatic cancer seven years ago, there had been a brief, terrible argument at the wake. Agnes had said something about God's plan. Joanna had said something about God's absence. They hadn't spoken since.
Now this.
Joanna pushed back from the table and walked to the window. Below, a fox was picking its way along the garden wall, unbothered by the drizzle. She watched it until it disappeared behind the bins.
Sister Brigid Norris. The name meant nothing to her. But the phrase *the police came and went in half a day* sat in her chest like a stone.
She knew that feeling. She'd built a career on that feeling—or she had, once, before the career had built a wall and she'd walked into it.
Joanna Rowe had been, for eleven years, an investigative journalist. She'd worked for the *Sunday Herald*, then freelanced for the broadsheets, then spent two years on a story about institutional abuse in care homes that had won a press award and changed precisely nothing. But it was the story after that—the one she hadn't published—that had ended everything.
David Paulson. A whistleblower at a pharmaceutical company, a quiet man with a wife and two daughters who'd come to her with documents proving his employer had suppressed trial data on a paediatric drug. She'd spent four months building the piece. Then the lawyers had got involved—the paper's lawyers, not the company's—and the story had been pulled. *Too much risk. Insufficient corroboration. We'll revisit it next quarter.*
They never revisited it. David Paulson, exposed as the source through a leak Joanna still couldn't trace, lost his job, his marriage, and finally, on a grey morning in November, his nerve. He'd driven his car into a reservoir near Swindon. The daughters were nine and twelve.
Joanna had left journalism six months later. She told people she wanted a change. She told herself she was tired. The truth was simpler and uglier: she had failed David Paulson, and she could not trust herself not to fail someone else.
So she taught. Media studies at a college in Camden, where the students were bright and idealistic and had not yet learned that the truth was only as powerful as the institution willing to publish it. She was good at teaching. She was not good at much else anymore.
She picked up Agnes's letter again.
*I saw things that don't make sense.*
The journalist in her—the one she'd tried to bury beneath lesson plans and marking schemes—stirred like something waking from a long sleep.
She opened her laptop and searched for "Sister Brigid Norris" and "Wellow Ash." Nothing. She tried "nun death Somerset" and got a handful of results—a brief item in the *Frome Standard* about a "tragic death" at a private retreat center, no details, no follow-up. She searched for "St. Dunstan's Retreat" and found a website that looked like it had been designed in 2008: a photograph of a handsome Georgian manor surrounded by gardens, a mission statement about spiritual renewal, and a biography of the center's director.
Father Rupert Veitch.
The photograph showed a man in his late fifties, silver-haired, with the kind of face that belonged on the dust jacket of a thoughtful memoir. Strong jaw, deep-set eyes, a smile that managed to be both warm and serious. His biography was impressive: ordained at twenty-five, served in parishes across Ireland and the north of England, developed a ministry focused on spiritual healing and what the website called "the restoration of souls in crisis." He'd been featured on Radio 4, written a column for *The Tablet*, and been profiled in the *Telegraph* as "one of the most compelling voices in modern Catholicism."
Joanna stared at his photograph for a long time.
Then she picked up her phone and called the college. "It's Joanna Rowe. I need to take some personal leave. Family matter in Somerset. I'm not sure how long—a week, maybe two."
The department secretary, a patient woman named Gloria, said she'd arrange cover. "Everything all right?"
"Fine," Joanna said. "Just something I need to look into."
She packed a bag that evening—jeans, boots, her old waxed jacket, a notebook, a digital recorder she hadn't used in three years. She hesitated over the recorder, then dropped it in. Old habits.
The drive down took three hours the next morning. The M3 gave way to the A303, then to narrower roads that wound through hills still brown with winter. Somerset revealed itself gradually: rolling farmland, church spires, villages that looked like they'd been assembled from a jigsaw puzzle box. She stopped for petrol outside Shepton Mallet and asked the attendant about Wellow Ash.
"Quiet place," the man said, not looking up from his phone. "Not much there."
"What about the retreat center? St. Dunstan's?"
He glanced at her then. "You going there?"
"Visiting someone who works there."
He nodded slowly. "Right. Well. It's up the hill on the far side of the village. Can't miss it." He paused. "They keep to themselves, that lot."
Joanna thanked him and drove on.
Wellow Ash was smaller than she'd expected—a single street of stone cottages, a pub called The Lamb and Flag, a church with a squat Norman tower, a village shop with a faded awning. The kind of place that appeared on calendars and concealed its secrets behind net curtains.
She drove through the village and up a lane that climbed steeply between hedgerows. At the top, a pair of iron gates stood open, flanked by stone pillars topped with moss-covered urns. A discreet sign read: *St. Dunstan's Retreat Centre — Private.*
The drive curved through an avenue of bare limes and opened onto a gravel forecourt. The manor house was beautiful in the way that Georgian buildings often are—symmetrical, proportioned, confident. Pale stone, tall windows, a porticoed entrance. But there was something else, too, something Joanna felt before she could articulate it. A stillness that went beyond quiet. The kind of silence that felt enforced.
She parked and sat for a moment, hands on the wheel. Through the windscreen, a figure moved behind one of the ground-floor windows and then was gone.
Joanna got out, shouldered her bag, and walked to the front door. It was painted black and fitted with a heavy brass knocker in the shape of a cross. She lifted it and let it fall.
The sound echoed.
A long pause. Then footsteps, and the door opened.
Agnes Rowe stood in the doorway. She was seventy-three now, though she might have been eighty from the look of her. She'd always been thin, but this was something else—a whittled quality, as if the years had been taking material away. Her grey hair was pulled back in a bun. Her eyes, behind wire-rimmed glasses, were the same pale blue as Joanna's mother's had been, and they were filled with something Joanna hadn't expected.
Relief. Pure, overwhelming relief.
"You came," Agnes said. Her voice cracked on the second word.
"I came," Joanna said.
Agnes reached out and gripped Joanna's hand with both of hers. Her fingers were cold and very strong.
"Come inside," she said. "Quickly. Before anyone sees."